Showing posts with label culture. Show all posts
Showing posts with label culture. Show all posts

Wednesday, 13 February 2008

A Culture of Change

Mention the phrase ‘new initiative’ to most teachers, and you’ll see them visibly recoil. Yet this Wednesday, Ed Balls announced the latest in a seemingly unending line of initiatives that would undoubtedly revolutionise teaching. This time, the target was ‘culture’, a subject hard to define in any circumstances, not least within the prescriptive confines of the standardised National Curriculum.

Each pupil should experience a minimum of five hours per week ‘high culture’, so say the Government, although how this should be delivered is anyone’s guess. The Telegraph seems to imply the introduction of a daily ‘Culture Hour’
, presumably in the same vein as the Literacy Hour, would be the Government’s intention. Although a cultural framework similar to the National Literacy Strategy (NLS) would be extremely difficult to construct.

For once, in fact, the DCSF are being very vague about what they expect schools to do. The guidance given on launch of the scheme, simply states schoolchildren should experience:

“Five hours of arts and culture a week, in and outside of the school day. This will include the chance to:

· perform on stage and attend top quality performances, exhibitions at museums and galleries, and heritage sites;
· get hands-on experience of the creative industries including film making, radio and TV;
· learn a musical instrument, and take part in a musical performance in front of an audience;
· produce creative writing and appreciate authors and how they work;
· learn about - and practise – new media and digital art; and
· develop art and craft skills.”


Very little of this is new content, with at least the final four examples already forming part of the National Curriculum in Literacy and English, Music, Art and ICT. Despite this, there has been a huge reaction from teachers, who feel their timetables are already stretched. Speaking in The Guardian, NUT General Secretary Steve Sinnott said:

"We still have an overloaded curriculum, particularly in primary schools. Its clutter needs to be stripped out to enable schools to be culturally creative."

Having experienced firsthand the struggle to deliver the intensive curriculum in primary schools, this is a point which I fully understand. However, the benefit of bringing so-called ‘high culture’ to those whose background and finance usually exclude them, is a massive one. The arts are historically incredibly elitist both as a patron and inside the industry. Initiatives, however ill-thought-out, that attempt to break these barriers and allow children into a world they didn’t know was open to them, can only be a good thing.

Some, however, such as Simon Heffer in the Telegraph, do not see any benefit whatsoever to such schemes.

“How was it that we had Chaucer, Shakespeare, Milton or Wordsworth without their having the inestimable benefit of Arts Council poetry workshops?”

This frankly ridiculous argument, continued throughout the article and echoed by many another middle-class commentator, seems to completely miss the point of what the scheme aims to achieve. There will always be prodigies, talents and revolutionaries within our society; those who rise to fame and fortune with no help from the state or any others. However, funding access to the arts for everyone is about showing young people they have the opportunity to do something they never realised was an option. Opening up children’s minds and inspiring them to a myriad of possibilities – isn’t that what education is supposed to be about?