Showing posts with label graduate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label graduate. Show all posts

Wednesday, 12 March 2008

Mickey Mouse Studies

In 2003, then Higher Education Minister Margaret Hodge branded certain degree courses, such as Media Studies, "Mickey Mouse" degrees. Five years later, research has been published suggesting she may have been justified. The QCA report aimed to compare standards between subjects at A-Level, to decide once and for all whether some were 'easy options'.

Although the report itself found "little evidence that the A-level subjects sometimes described as 'soft' were any less demanding than their more established counterparts", the headline most of the papers chose to go for, was some form of "Media Studies is easy." Indeed, there was a 'slightly' lower standard of work expected of students in Media Studies at grades A and E compared to those achieving the same grades in English and History. However, the study did not take into account coursework, some 40% of the marks! The only place in the mainstream press I found that picked up on the unreliability was the Guardian's 'mortarboard' blog.

"According to Cambridge Assessment's research director, the QCA book on comparability was "high quality", but the report was a "highly defective" mixture of unreliable results and contradictory assertions.

This is the real story - that the research is so poor. But will anyone heed this complaint? Sadly, what is most likely to stick in peoples' minds, confirming unfair assumptions as it seems to, is that media studies is somehow less worthy. Is it?"

That is an interesting question. Public perception tends to be that yes, Media Studies is an easy ride and doesn't actually mean anything. The more classical subjects such as the aforementioned English and History are seen to have more depth and substance to them, and a qualification in them to be somehow more impressive. However, in today's world, the media has an infinite amount more power and influence in society than any Emily Bronte novel or William Blake poem. The key themes of life and love, triumph and tragedy, sex, drugs and religion can be as easily analysed through a catalogue of screen offerings, as through the works of literature. As History defines the past, Media defines the present. How this can be seen as unworthy, I do not know.

Saying that, there was a specific reason I chose not to take Media Studies myself; it is seen as a joke by the very industry its students hope to by employed in. The full title of my degree is "New Media Journalism with PR", yet when I'm asked I drop the "New Media" prefix. It somehow has more gravitas, although changes nothing of the nature of the course. This writer in the Independent sums up the attitudes of many media professionals I have spoken to in the past.

"Journalism is just a trade where the gifted, the average and the incompetent sit side by side in the same office producing work of varying quality. Least of all is it an academic discipline, though undertaking a demanding course in something else at university is the best preparation for it. Were I still an editor, I wouldn't offer a job to a graduate in media studies; I would always prefer that the applicant had been tested in one of the older disciplines"

As a fast-moving young industry, these old-school attitudes about the subject may die out in a matter of years. Until then, Media Studies is certainly not the easy option; for those who want a career in the media, it may be the hardest option of all.

(For those interested in the full QCA report you can find it here.)

Thursday, 21 February 2008

Educating into debt

The Guardian this week published statistics showing Universities to be in a state of serious debt crisis. Some, such as Manchester University, owe as much as £12.4million.

Despite this, Phil Harding, chairman of the British Universities Finance Directors Group, doesn't seem at all worried. He said, in the Guardian:

"I think we are borrowing with a degree of confidence and a reasonable expectation the cap on tuition fees will either come off or be lifted so that universities will be able to charge higher fees."

So, the plan is seemingly to spend now in anticipation of increased income from students in the future. The wisdom of this is questionable. With fees already in excess of £3,000 per year, is it fair to expect students to pay so much? An Equifax study last week estimated the average student starting university this year will graduate with £30,000 of debt. Yet the strategy still appears to be to solve institutional debt crisis by causing individual debt crises. We are educating our students into debt and that cannot be good. With consumer indebtedness at record levels, the culture of borrowing is one that should be counteracted, not encouraged.

The Liberal Democrats have a different theory about funding of higher education, which often makes them popular amongst students. Speaking in The Guardian, their higher education and skills spokesman Stephen Williams said:

"Universities should be making a plea for extra central government funds rather than anticipating passing the bill on to future students."

This standpoint makes more sense to me, as individuals shouldering such massive burdens of debt before even considering a mortgage, is surely undesirable. Donald MacLeod in the Guardian makes the point that "on the average graduate salary of £18,000, repayments are £5.19 a week. In that sense, it's more like a tax." If that is the case, then why not just rebrand it as a graduate tax? The Sutton Trust report claims that it is the perception rather than reality of debt that is deterring poorer students from University. As someone who has spent periods as a full-time taxpayer as well as a student, I would have no problems with paying extra tax to support future students through Higher Education.

Thames Valley University, where I am a student, was noted in the Guardian piece as one of the worst indebted. The Guardian reported the debt at £5.8million, whereas the Times Higher Education Supplement quotes a deficit last year of £6.5million.

Yet today, it was revealed the institution is undertaking a restructuring programme that will include a £60million spend on estates. Questions of priorities arise when, from a student's perspective, it appears money is being spent on repainting corridors when people struggle to find a functioning computer in certain faculty buildings. Within this development budget, is included a £6.7million grant from the government. It will be interesting to see if the results provide the 'value for money' the government demands from its public services.